Advice needed scoping work for electrician

Talk Electrician Forum

Help Support Talk Electrician Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Chel

Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2023
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Location
Durham
Hi, I'm a homeowner looking for some advice on how to pitch (potentially piecemeal) to one or more electricians/firms a large project, and whether or not what I'm pitching is sensible - before I spend too much money. That has brought me as a brand new member to this forum. I hope my question is in the right place; if not I expect that the mods can relocate it. It's a long post to provide sufficient context so I've skipped what I feel is unnecessary in an introductory post, but can expand if helpful.

I own a detached house in County Durham on a 60A supply where my current usage spike is 45A. I have been watching videos on home battery systems for several years - since before the energy crisis and ESS becoming a 'craze' - and I really want to implement my own system to reduce my bills (£800/month), transition to electric rather than fossil fuels, and as it's a personal interest. I've never been in a financial position to act upon my interest but that has changed recently so I want to start the project and use my money wisely, though I don't have the funds to pull the trigger on the whole thing - only to tackle 'phase 1', batteries & inverters.

I am more keen on energy storage and time-shifting my usage to cheap night-time rates than I am on generating my own electricity - not least because I would need to replace an old roof before I could install PV panels. So I want a large battery array (daily usage typically 20-25kWh, annual usage 9MWh), a decent inverter, to load up the batteries overnight, and to be entirely 'off grid' outside of cheap night-time rates, with no intention for grid export (initially). For this I intend to use Victron inverters and components and Pylontech rack-mounted batteries; fairly standard gear for those not wanting an off-the-shelf solution.

The overall 'project' has a lot of potential and future arms and legs. Currently space heating, domestic hot water, and cooking is via gas (36MWh annual), and in time that will be shifted to electric (ASHP for the heating - I already have wet UFH). My closed loop hot water cylinder has 5kW auxilliery immersion coil. I have 2 ICE cars that will be replaced with EVs in the near future. Once I replace the roof I will potentially install PV, though the array would be small due to roof profile (8 facets). In considering these future extensions I wish for a flexible design that allows for expansion. My concern is the 4-hour overnight window and the fact that I would need to draw down a lot of energy to fill the batteries (30kWh in near future, expanding to accommodate future transition to electric), run the immersion, charge the cars, run household loads including washing machine / tumble dryer. My existing 60A 1 phase supply would never cope so would need to be upgraded to either 100A (if the local grid could accommodate) or to a 3 phase connection (if not price-prohibitive).

I'm a IT project manager by trade, so my first thought was to list my requirements, put together a very high-level plan (4 major phases, each with benefits that mean they can be staged with years between each if necessary), and engage with a company that could consult/design/deliver on this. I reached out to a number of companies - not one-man-bands, not national firms, but a few in between - and only had one willing to visit site and quote me. Rather than issue a quote, however, they responded after 3 weeks to inform me that the project was too large for them. Whether that is the truth, or the fact that I knew what I wanted was not an off-the-shelf option, or because engagement with DNO / energy company was too difficult, I am unsure. It's definitely possible that they viewed the job as more trouble than it was worth.

I can't start DIYing this due to the current position of the meter box, explained later. This leaves me in a position where I am struggling to get the work off the ground and need to know how I could alternatively pitch it. My current thinking is to break it down into discrete work packages, likely dropping the idea of 3 phase supply and major DNO engagement, and get these work packages delivered without necessarily the need to discuss the wider project. But that means that there's no competent design authority (I'd consider myself half-way there; I know enough to get into trouble). Thus I'm looking for some confirmation / validation that I'm approaching it in the correct way and not making a mistake.

The first work package, I think, is to relocate my supply to the garage. I have no external meterbox; currently the supply cable enters the property beside my front door. Inside I have a small cupboard hosting the cutout, smart meter, and consumer unit. This location isn't at all appropriate for batteries / inverter etc., which would be much more appropriately sited in the garage some 12m away. The reason for relocating my supply rather than just hooking into the existing 40A garage circuit or as a new single-legged circuit from the consumer unit is that I wish to use the Victron gear as a UPS, in off-grid mode during the day with anti-islanding in case of power failure. This requires that the critical loads (and I am considering the entirety of my current usage as critical load) must be behind the inverter. I'm comfortable in my understanding of what equipment is needed for this (that is, discussing inverter brands isn't the purpose of this initial request for advice). Thus I don't just want the inverter simply connected to the existing consumer unit, I want it between the smart meter and the consumer unit. To achieve this I do not believe (though am willing to be corrected) that I need to engage the DNO to 'relocate supply' (Northern Powergrid application process is not particularly user-friendly). Instead, where I currently have 50cm tails from the smart meter to the consumer unit (via two-pole breaker), I believe I can instead have a 12m run between the smart meter and the inverter, and a 12m run back between the inverter and the consumer unit. In doing so I can fit one or more new consumer units in the garage, beside the inverter, ready for future expansion (ASHP, EVSE, electric hob), making the garage area the master and the existing consumer unit a sub-panel.

Relocating the supply (or, rather, relocating the 'master' area) would be a discrete job, would not require an electrician specialising in inverters / batteries / EVSE, and would leave me in a position to continue the next steps of batteries and inverter separately. Is this a viable start to the project? It gets high-amperage power to where I need it to be. I'm aware that there are regs regarding the length of meter tails, but the replacement of the tails would be by way of 2 proper 100A 230V twin and earth cables (trenched and in conduit; armoured?). My overhead supply is far more precarious: 70-year-old separate aerial line and neutrals (6 inches air-gapped) from the pole to the exterior of my neighbour's house (15m, not a looped supply) and thence to my own building (10m) two stories up, before tracking a further 15m as twin-core to the point of ingress (CPC via earth rod rather than via supply). So the DNO is clearly happy with this 40m of not-the-best quality cabling; are the regs happy with me effectively extending this a further 24m via high quality cables?

My preference is that the run to the garage should be underground, in conduit, trenched through an old asphalt driveway which will be replaced at a later date. The trench would cross perpendicular to and under my property's water supply, gas supply, and two 6" sewer lines (rainwater). I intend to have the cable burial as part of the initial work package; that the electrician can supply / organise the trenching or at lease recommend / liaise with a suitable company. Is this realistic? I have attached a high-level diagram of the trenching proposed. Having run out of better ideas I intend to post this first work package as a job on MyBuilder. Would that be a mistake?

I have made an application / formal quote request to Northern Powergrid to upgrade my cutout from 60A to 100A. In separating the work packages like this and losing design authority I need to either give up on the idea of 3 phase supply (and my dreams of 2x 22kW EVSE) or at least defer it, as I don't have the expertise to make complicated DNO applications without assistance from an electrician.

Thank you sincerely to all those who have read this far, and even moreso in advance to anyone able to offer constructive feedback.

Trench Plan.PNG
 
How on Earth do you spend £9600 per year on electricity?

also how do you think the majority of electricity is generated?
 
Last edited:
How on Earth do you spend £9600 per year on electricity?

also how do you think the majority of electricity is generated?
Hence the project. Energy spend is 50/50 gas and electric. This exercise will reduce by ~75% the cost of the electricity (so 37% overall reduction) increasing as I transition from gas to electric.

Regarding generation, that's a topic for a different thread; I'm aware of the current grid source but that is changing each year.
 
I would not use my builder Or check a con man.

Ask friends and neighbours for recommendations
Thanks; I think I knew I didn't want to be using My builder or the like. I do have a spark who previously indicated that he wasn't qualified for the likes of 3 phase applications and batteries so I mentally wrote him off, but this first step doesn't involve that so might be within his level of comfort then.

As to the approach to the project, and this first work package, does it seem sensible?
 
For the spark, or for this forum? Totally agree regarding the spark, think I overloaded those previous.
 
My take would be get the DNO involved, move the supply to the garage and upgrade it at the same time.

Get the trench dug and lay an armoured cable ready to connect the house to the new supply in the garage.

Fill out the forms for DNO with details of your inverter etc and your intended operation.

Once the supplies are in, mount the inverter on the wall and get your batteries ready, get a sparkie to run main into the inverter with the guidance from here, connected as you want it i.e. grid >> inverter >> house.

That gets you up and running in easy steps.
 
My overhead supply is far more precarious: 70-year-old separate aerial line and neutrals (6 inches air-gapped) from the pole to the exterior of my neighbour's house (15m, not a looped supply) and thence to my own building (10m) two stories up, before tracking a further 15m as twin-core to the point of ingress (CPC via earth rod rather than via supply). So the DNO is clearly happy with this 40m of not-the-best quality cabling; are the regs happy with me effectively extending this a further 24m via high quality cables?

I intend to post this first work package as a job on MyBuilder. Would that be a mistake?

All cabling prior to your incoming supply meter is the property and responsibility of the DNO...
They do not come under guidance of BS7671 wiring regulations...

So compliance with "The Regs" as you call it, only starts from your meter tails and consumer unit onward..

And, unless there is some significant danger that has been reported to them, anything before your meter, (including the supply cables and cut out fuse),
is up to what the DNO think they are happy with on the day the last DNO person paid a visit!!!!!!!!!!


Regarding sites like: My-Bodger, Check-A-****, Trusted-Cash-Generator etc...
they are just an extra link in the chain who want some more of your money, paid for by the contractors who they list on their sites charging more to cover their monthly subscriptions to be listed.. and/or in some cases to purchase the contact details for the prospective jobs listed...

Whilst they claim to have vetted and checked tradespersons, there is an immediate conflict of interest as these tradespersons are the key businesses who are generating their running costs & profits!!
{Key questions are:- Why would they remove a contractor who is paying their wages...
AND... who pays for all those expensive TV adverts and/or sports sponsorship ?}

Any half decent tradesperson will will not need to waste their money giving their hard-earned cash to the increasing number of finding-tradespersons-websites, that keep appearing..

From my experience, it is generally new start-up, inexperienced or very poor tradespeople, who cannot generate enough of their own word-of-mouth recommendations that choose to spend money to be listed on these sort of sites..
(I may be wrong... BUT... I would never entertain using these sort of rip-off merchants..
{self employed since Feb 1999 with plenty of recommendations})

Have you tried looking on the social media sites such as, Nextdoor/BookFace etc?
They often have recommendations from local people about local traders..
(I know I have been recommended numerous times on social media..
No fee's No money to pay.. Just FREE real local recommendations for various trades?)


As you say... forget all that later project stuff at the moment...

Start off with finding someone to reposition the main incoming supply and
Upgrade it to the capacity you think you will be needing... (This will also need DNO involvement.)

Get a SWA from the existing CU to the proposed incoming supply position....
Once new upgraded supply is in place..
Power can be connected to the existing CU via your SWA...

Then you can start thinking about all your next steps...
However a 60A single phase supply to a three phase supply could well be quite expensive..
But that is very much dependant upon your DNO!!!!!!!!

You really do need some DNO costings to assess if the feasibility of your later projects are do-able?

I cannot comment on what other parts of the country do or don't do...
But anything other than single phase 80A (18000kVA), for a domestic dwelling, could involve a few more hoops to jump through..?
 
Last edited:
It could be cheaper to build a small service box to DNO standards at the edge of your property and have the cutbout and meters installed in there.

Then from there you can basically do what you wish ducting wise (to regulations) as its on your property.

There are alot of requirements regarding colour of ducting for DNO supply cables. They must be red, buried at a certain depth, will require inspecting prior to the DNO running their cable into it.

If you put up a meter building you only have to provide a red duct from that to the edge of your property. After that you can run your duct however you like. It doesn't have to be inspected as it's yours.

Also you can request a 3phase supply be installed, but until your ready to use 3 phase only have a single phase meter installed. This will save you money as you won't be paying for 2 phases your not using until you are.

Cable sizes will have to be calculated with voltdrop in mind. You may end up installing a 5core 35/50mm swa to account for this.

The starting point is the DNO. But remember you don't have to use them to do all the work as there are now independent companies who can make connections to the grid as long as the DNO has approved them.

Hope this helps.
 
I would install the inverter and batteries in the Study, adjacent to the CU.
Some of the inverter and battery units have sleek cases and are not that intrusive.
Or you could install behind a partition wall with several access doors, fan ventilated if necessary.
Or even IP rated units outside, next to the front door.
Armoured cable for the EVSE could then be run along the bottom of the exterior wall to the garage.
Saves extending the supply underground.
And I can't imagine the difficulty of moving the rings, spurs, and lighting to the new CU position.
"My concern is the 4-hour overnight window"
You're not limited to only charging overnight, you can charge for all of the Economy 7 hours.
 
Get the trench dug and lay an armoured cable ready to connect the house to the new supply in the garage.
Looking at the OP's plan it would probably be better installing ducting with access chamber(s), installing 2 or 3 parallel ducts would give some flexibility in the long term in case today's crystal ball fails to forsee future technology advances
But anything other than single phase 80A (18000kVA), for a domestic dwelling, could involve a few more hoops to jump through..?
Typo alert 18000kVA is a very big supply and well into substation territory most domestic properties would be 18000VA or 18kVA


With regard to the OP trying to get quotes on what your proposing will likely be an uphill battle without any overall timescale and with material prices at the moment being very volatile at best you might get some estimate of prices but I doubt anyone committing to a quote for long term work without it being very significantly loaded (wholesalers quoting me on armoured cable recently would only hold the quoted price for 7 days), while prices and product supply may start to stabilise in the next 6 - 12 months nothing is guaranteed again if this is 2 - 5 year project the technology may have improved or significantly changed so designing a project where the options remain flexible until build completion maybe the best option as an example you are having the roof replaced so would it be viable to use PV tiles rather than fit PV panels later
Given your supply is overhead and to your neighbours property before yours it sounds like you have the old "mural wired" supply that was quite common 60 - 80 years ago and that may complicate any supply upgrade you want, I would be talking to the DNO before making an upgrade application or a better option get an electrician on board who can discuss possible upgrade solutions with the DNO to get an optimum solution before making a formal application as the upgrade work may need a trench or duct installation to the property boundary for a new underground supply and this could be done while doing the other trench work as part of the project. One of the problems with overhead DNO supplies is capacity especially the transformer usually stuck up a pole where the 11KV meets the local LV network I have seen some quite large quotes in the past for overhead upgrades especially in rural areas due to transformer and cable changes needed to meet the proposed capacity
 
Why on earth you would want to swap your gas for electric is way beyond me.. Gas is FAR cheaper..

Secondly, as you have an overhead supply, i assume that there is no underground mains cable in your street??? If this is the case you can forget a three phase supply.. If there IS an underground LV mains, you would be surprised how cheap a proper supply is, probably cheaper that running all the very large cable you would need to do it your way..

john..
 
It could be cheaper to build a small service box to DNO standards at the edge of your property and have the cutbout and meters installed in there.

Then from there you can basically do what you wish ducting wise (to regulations) as its on your property.

There are alot of requirements regarding colour of ducting for DNO supply cables. They must be red, buried at a certain depth, will require inspecting prior to the DNO running their cable into it.

If you put up a meter building you only have to provide a red duct from that to the edge of your property. After that you can run your duct however you like. It doesn't have to be inspected as it's yours.

Also you can request a 3phase supply be installed, but until your ready to use 3 phase only have a single phase meter installed. This will save you money as you won't be paying for 2 phases your not using until you are.

Cable sizes will have to be calculated with voltdrop in mind. You may end up installing a 5core 35/50mm swa to account for this.

The starting point is the DNO. But remember you don't have to use them to do all the work as there are now independent companies who can make connections to the grid as long as the DNO has approved them.

Hope this helps.
A DNO cable duct is BLACK twinwall duct. 2" diameter for a single phase supply and 4" for a three phase supply.

The DNO will usually supply the duct themselves..

The depth is 450mm to the top of the duct.

The supply will ONLY be installed ONCE the DNO have seen proof that you have contracted with a supplier [of electricity] This supplier will then come and fit a three phase meter. If you then say you only want a single phase meter i expect they will laugh at you, as they will have contracted with the DNO themselves as the supplier subsidises the installation cost

john..

john
 
Why on earth you would want to swap your gas for electric is way beyond me.. Gas is FAR cheaper..
Not if you use a heatpump it's not, it's just about equal in the worst conditions, when you venture away from the worst electricity and heatpump is cheaper. If you factor in the possibility of battery and solar it just gets better and better. I'm hoping by next winter to disconnect from gas completely.
 
Hello again. Thank you everyone for the helpful and informative replies; I've been reading them as they came in and mulling it over throughout the day (two kids under 5 leave little time for thoughtful replies).

To clarify (though perhaps a moot point) the existing supply, in the first image below the pole on the left is the terminal pole and has a 3-phase supply (my intended source). My current connection, as a pair of aerial wires, travels from the pole to the corner of the end terrace house and, unadulterated, from there jumps across to my house on the right (ignore the wires disappearing off the top - that's a single telephone wire doubled by google street view). The tall tree is between the pole and my house and is likely the reason that the connection is dog legged - though I bought in 2017, I've remembered now that my home was extended in 1998 and the connection must have been re-made as it traverses what was new construction. My connection contacts my home just where you can see the satelite dish poking over the hedge, moves to the front of the building and then horizontally to the drainpipe - you can see the black line above the left-hand window. It travels down behind the drain pipe to ingress at a height of about 2 metres.

My connection is not looped or shared as the houses to left of frame recieve their supply from the rear.

Existing Overhead.png

I know that the pole is 3 phase as somehow I got myself on the phone to the Design and Planning Manager at the DNO. In discussion with him I explained that I know 3 phase connections can cost anywhere from £2k to £15k+ for 'normal' residential connections (and I know it can be magnitudes of that for remote locations). The design manager said that this pole was 3-phase, did have capacity for my needs, and an underground connection would be very inexpensive in context - likely just a few thousand. On that basis I hoped that 3-phase was a possibility.

Below is a wider plan of the property, existing supply, and candidate new supply routes. The new supply would need to drop down from the pole and then be trenched by the DNO along the footpath to the point at which it crosses my property border. Red is preferred but might be cost prohibitive; blue might reduce the DNO cost to acceptable levels at the expense of additional trenching on my land. Part of the blue route is necessary either way to connect the garage to the existing CU to the left of the front door.

NPG Supply Route.png

The general advice that I have recieved in this thread, with some filtering, is that:
  1. I'm not barking mad, and the rough plan will work;
  2. I could 'move' my supply to the garage without DNO involvement - legging it out and back;
  3. It would be better to first attempt to move the supply formally with DNO involvement, and tie this in with a supply upgrade;
  4. To achieve my basic immediate aim (energy storage) would need an increase in my supply (DNO involvement) from 60A to 80A or 100A;
  5. To achieve my longer term aim would saturate a 1-phase supply and necessitate a 3-phase supply;
  6. The earlier I involve the DNO, the better.
A couple of days ago I submitted to the DNO a request for quotation for a single-phase upgrade (100A). This evening I have submitted a request for quotation for the 3-phase supply. The prices that I get back will dictate both my immediate plans and those long term.

I do find it frustrating that this is such a complex process (in general; not just with the DNO) for the home-owner. Aside from or even including the batteries, my plan isn't anything that I consider unreasonable. With the widespread move to EVs and goverment intent to phase out residential gas supplies in the medium term, many home owners are going to be doing exactly what I'm attempting: installing car charger(s), ASHP, immersion heaters, induction cookers. I would argue that these loads combine to a level that necessitates a 3-phase supply for many properties, and the overall process isn't easy. I believe that what I'm asking now will be the norm in a decade, and someone will need to create a better process, be that DNOs or government.


I thank you all again for the time taken to read and advise on my predicament. I'll keep this thread updated as I'm sure I will have more questions; currently I haven't managed to engage an electrician nor contacted my energy supplier (EON) to find out if they're even willing to fit a 3-phase smart meter, so there's a long road ahead.
 
A DNO cable duct is BLACK twinwall duct. 2" diameter for a single phase supply and 4" for a three phase supply.
It's BLACK or RED ENWL say red on the spec I had.

The supply will ONLY be installed ONCE the DNO have seen proof that you have contracted with a supplier [of electricity] This supplier will then come and fit a three phase meter. If you then say you only want a single phase meter i expect they will laugh at you, as they will have contracted with the DNO themselves as the supplier subsidises the installation cost

Not the case. Just had a customer do this hence how I know it's possible.
 
My take would be get the DNO involved, move the supply to the garage and upgrade it at the same time.

Get the trench dug and lay an armoured cable ready to connect the house to the new supply in the garage.

Fill out the forms for DNO with details of your inverter etc and your intended operation.

Once the supplies are in, mount the inverter on the wall and get your batteries ready, get a sparkie to run main into the inverter with the guidance from here, connected as you want it i.e. grid >> inverter >> house.

That gets you up and running in easy steps.
I think that would be a better job too..

john..
 
Top