My ONLY comment is get this reviewed onsite with minimum 3 competent sparks and make sure they quote "like for like" and all commit to providing you an EIC and LABC Part P certification....
Wiring Diagram Barn / Workshop
- Thread starter Magnet
- Start date
Help Support Talk Electrician Forum:
My ONLY comment is get this reviewed onsite with minimum 3 competent sparks and make sure they quote "like for like" and all commit to providing you an EIC and LABC Part P certification....
Just wow.
Have you read anything posted in this thread?
Why would anyone bother to give you any constructive criticism, you ignore it and do what you want anyway whilst moaning all the way.
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2009
- Messages
- 1,797
- Reaction score
- 267
Have read this whole thread in dismay, you have been advised several times on this thread, but just to keep it nice and simple, just give the spark a general layout drawing of where you want the sockets, switches and lights and let him get on with it.
I don't know any spark that would take this on with you ( a non spark) dictating the design to that detail.
I don't know any spark that would take this on with you ( a non spark) dictating the design to that detail.
Spanner or Hammer
Member
roys..
That's not a million miles from what I said yesterday before I lost the will to live...
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2009
- Messages
- 1,797
- Reaction score
- 267
I know, she has been told several times in the thread but she is not listening.
Her finger is on the the transmit button but she has never let it go to receive.
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2010
- Messages
- 14,621
- Reaction score
- 1,171
Bin the RCD units
fit a unit with a main switch and have an RCBO for every circuit
in my opinion a single RCD unit controlling more than one circuit is non compliant as you have not 'designed and installed circuits to minimise inconvenience......yard yahda yahda'
unless you consider and earth fault on ONE circuit tripping the supply to EVERYTHING on that board as not being inconvenient
just saying
fit a unit with a main switch and have an RCBO for every circuit
in my opinion a single RCD unit controlling more than one circuit is non compliant as you have not 'designed and installed circuits to minimise inconvenience......yard yahda yahda'
unless you consider and earth fault on ONE circuit tripping the supply to EVERYTHING on that board as not being inconvenient
just saying
<unsubscribe>
Someone please tell me then this is all over.
Someone please tell me then this is all over.
you said in post 54 that the sparky would be doing it, in which case they would be doing the design, so WTGrape are you still here for?
as for 12 of us again 1, have you ever thought that maybe the 12 of us are right, and you are wrong?
but anyway, get on with it yourself, you clearly know better than anyone else. still wondering why you are not doing the construction and I&T of it anyway since us mere sparks are not good enough
From my many years of experience of being told by customers that they know far more about design and installation than I do I've formulated a plan.
Other than that just walk away and don't look back.
Other than that just walk away and don't look back.
Last edited by a moderator:
I can lend you a baseball bat.
I can see the logic there Tony.
I can discourage them from out of arms ( claws ) reach :B
Beetyboop..
Now, i know you are having a stab at designing this installation, but honestly, you are wasting your time.. Whoever goes to install it, will obviously want to do all the cable sizing and the myriad of other calculations themselves for the following reason; They know full well, that if they install the thing as YOU have designed, AND and at final inspection it does not comply, [more on this later] then, they WILL NOT energise the thing, and you will not be a happy bunny, and presumably refuse to pay them.
Now, as anyone capable of doing the design work will obviously have the common sense to realise this, they will want you to sign, as BS7671 requires, that YOU PERSONALLY are responsible for the design. IF THEN it turns out not to comply, they will sue you to get paid AND WIN. But who wants the hassle???
Nobody sensible will do it....
So you say you got an HNC in mechanical engineering?? So tango'd what, there are people on here with TWO degrees, one in electrical and one in mechanical..
Now, you seem to be a bit "hung up" on this idea of "final inspection" You do realise that it does not quite work like that, the process of inspection is a continual one all through the process of actually installing stuff. You do not just complete an installation then fart about with a meter for a bit and pronounce it is "ok" It is not as simple as that.
So, as i have shown, the installer will have do do all the calcs anyway, so you are not going to save anything, just complicate matters..
Stick to what you know.. I can calculate deflections of beams, reactions at the ends, and do BM diagrams, BUT, this does not mean i am a structural engineer and can design bridges..[Hmm, now what is this web bearing and buckling business all about]
Just let the electrician do it all. and then, if it DOES go **** up [unfortunate choice of words!] YOU will be in the clear. Get it wrong and you may well indeed end up "**** up".....
john
Now, i know you are having a stab at designing this installation, but honestly, you are wasting your time.. Whoever goes to install it, will obviously want to do all the cable sizing and the myriad of other calculations themselves for the following reason; They know full well, that if they install the thing as YOU have designed, AND and at final inspection it does not comply, [more on this later] then, they WILL NOT energise the thing, and you will not be a happy bunny, and presumably refuse to pay them.
Now, as anyone capable of doing the design work will obviously have the common sense to realise this, they will want you to sign, as BS7671 requires, that YOU PERSONALLY are responsible for the design. IF THEN it turns out not to comply, they will sue you to get paid AND WIN. But who wants the hassle???
Nobody sensible will do it....
So you say you got an HNC in mechanical engineering?? So tango'd what, there are people on here with TWO degrees, one in electrical and one in mechanical..
Now, you seem to be a bit "hung up" on this idea of "final inspection" You do realise that it does not quite work like that, the process of inspection is a continual one all through the process of actually installing stuff. You do not just complete an installation then fart about with a meter for a bit and pronounce it is "ok" It is not as simple as that.
So, as i have shown, the installer will have do do all the calcs anyway, so you are not going to save anything, just complicate matters..
Stick to what you know.. I can calculate deflections of beams, reactions at the ends, and do BM diagrams, BUT, this does not mean i am a structural engineer and can design bridges..[Hmm, now what is this web bearing and buckling business all about]
Just let the electrician do it all. and then, if it DOES go **** up [unfortunate choice of words!] YOU will be in the clear. Get it wrong and you may well indeed end up "**** up".....
john
Would it be chauvinistic to imply that OP should just make the hot drinks while an experienced fully qualified electrician does the job from design right through to testing ? Bloody women's lib have a lot to answer for... :facepalm:
Chauvinism has nothing to do with it as far as l can see.
It's more to do with dented pride and the inability to accept advice as advice and not criticism.
If we were all omnipotent and omnificent threads like this wouldn't exist.
It's more to do with dented pride and the inability to accept advice as advice and not criticism.
If we were all omnipotent and omnificent threads like this wouldn't exist.
Is this still running !! :C
Like diarrhea.
Magnet
"Was Beetyboop44"
I am yawning ever so much . :B
Similar threads
- Locked
